Quoting primetime21:

Quote:
Quoting DaMikstar:

Quote:
Quoting Kvack:

Quote:
I just had an update (which I thought was correct) get shot down. My update removed Features from a UHD release which were only present on the Blu-ray included with that release. Was my update incorrect? If so, I won't make updates like that going forward.

Putting what the rules say about this aside, my personal preference is to only include the Features on the Child release if they are not present on the parent (assuming that the child release is a copy of the movie and not just a bonus features disc).

You are incorrect. The rules are perfectly clear about this. Combos are to be entered as normal profiles which means that all features belong to the main profile. But you are allowed to use a child profile for the included lesser medium.

There are just 2-3 users who want to push their opinion and this is going on for years now. But they never got their way and are still hammering.

Those contributions which remove features from combo profiles are almost everytime rejected and if not the contributions which correct this are always accepted even with a few NO-votes.

It's hysterical when you put "2-3 users" when literally the votes here are more than 3 to 1 in favor of what is clearly stated in the rules.  Seems like you're looking in a mirror when you're pointing fingers.

It's exactly what it is. It's just you and one or two other American contributors who contribute like this. All other contributors I come across worldwide include the extras in the main profile where they belong.

You know what's really hysterical? Someone who thinks that a poll in a rarely visited forum actually has any significance. And someone who doesn't realise that your way get's rejected all the time while entering all bonus to the main profile always goes through even with some of your fellow No-Voters trying to vote it down. Anyway, seems like I'm repeating myself.

Quoting DaMikstar:

Quote:
There is a reason, most of the remaining contributors put everything into the main (Main not parent for a reason!) profile.

OK, here is one simple question: Does the bonus material belong to a specific included cut or only to the included HD version or any other disc including the same movie or does it belong to the movie itself. If you think it belongs to the movie it should be clear where it should be mentioned.

But yes, there is one feature that usually belongs to a specific cut: an audio commentary.

That may be why people do it, but it doesn't follow the clearly stated rules.